Mr. Clemens on the federal government’s interest in the home addresses of seventy-nine million Medicaid patients
A letter to the editor, from the desk of Mr. Samuel L. Clemens, lately of the river, now of the waiting room, where I have been asked to fill out a form
To the Editor:
Sir —
A correspondent, a man of sound instincts and short patience, has written to ask me a question that I think deserves a reply in print. He says that, so far as he is aware, persons who are in this country without papers are not eligible to receive Medicaid, and neither are they eligible for Medicare, and so he would like to know why the Immigration and Customs Enforcement agency has been going through the medical rolls of the American people in search of them.
It is the sort of question that sounds simple, and, as with most of the simple questions I have been asked in my life, the answer is that it depends on what you mean by “going through,” and on whom.
Let me take the facts in order, for I find them more diverting than any invention of mine.
In July of last year, the Associated Press reported that the Department of Health and Human Services and the Department of Homeland Security had signed an agreement giving ICE access to the personal information of every one of the country’s seventy-nine million Medicaid enrollees. This included their names, addresses, birth dates, racial and ethnic background, and Social Security numbers. The agreement, the AP says, was not announced. It permitted ICE to look at the data between nine in the morning and five in the afternoon, Monday through Friday, which I thought a nice touch, as though the intention were to keep a respectable office, the way a pickpocket might keep banker’s hours.
The stated purpose, according to the Department of Homeland Security, was to ensure that illegal aliens are not receiving Medicaid benefits meant for law-abiding Americans. This is a perfectly reasonable thing to want, and I would not wish to sneer at it. The government has a duty to see that its money goes where the law says it should. Data on Medicaid enrollees is routinely exchanged between the states and Washington for just that reason. A federal judge in San Francisco, who was otherwise critical of how the thing was done, observed that this kind of basic data sharing is clearly authorized by statute.
But the agreement itself, in the sentence that I find most instructive, states that ICE will use the data to receive “identity and location information” on persons ICE has already identified. I would ask the reader to dwell on the word “location.” A man who wishes to know whether another man is being paid money he should not be paid does not, as a rule, require his street address. A man who wishes to find him does.
Which brings me back to my correspondent’s question, and to the part of it that is not as simple as he supposed. It is true that federal Medicaid money cannot be used to cover people who are in the country illegally. It is also true that the law requires emergency Medicaid for anyone who walks into a hospital in need of it, whatever his papers, and that nearly half of the states, including some governed by Republicans, spend their own money to cover certain groups, children and pregnant women among them, regardless of immigration status. And it is true, besides, that a great many households contain persons of mixed standing. A child born in this country is an American citizen and entitled to the program, and the address on that child’s file may also be the address of a parent who is not.
So the answer to the question is that the undocumented are mostly not on the rolls, but a good many people near them are. And the government, having looked at the list, may now be said to have an interest in the home of every single one.
There has been, as is the custom of this country, a lawsuit. More than twenty states and the District of Columbia brought it. A federal judge in San Francisco found last August that the government’s policies were “totally unclear” and did not seem to be the product of a coherent decision. In December, the judge allowed ICE to pull some basic data, such as addresses, phone numbers, and birth dates, in the states that sued, but ordered it to keep away from the data of citizens and lawful permanent residents and from sensitive medical information. In the twenty-eight states that did not sue, I am told, the court set no limits whatever. And in the spring the states told the court that the federal health department had admitted sharing with ICE what it called “a large and complex” body of data, which they say seems to ignore the order. The administration has not, so far as I know, explained how it distinguishes a lawful resident from an unlawful one in a database that was not built for the purpose.
I am a humorist, not a physician, but I know something of what happens when people are afraid of doctors. They do not stop being sick. I am told by those who work in the clinics that parents have begun to ask whether signing their citizen children up for coverage might put the family on a list. I take this to be the real product of the arrangement, whether or not it was the intention: a nation of mothers who will not take a child to the doctor because the doctor’s paperwork has an address on it.
A libertarian think tank in Washington, the sort that has never been accused of sympathy for the other party’s causes, has put the question in a headline: why is ICE spying on citizens’ medical data? I commend the question. I do not know that anyone has yet answered it in language that would pass for plain.
I remain, sir, as ever,
Mark Twain
(deceased, and therefor