Mr. Clemens on the camera company that has resolved to supervise its own customers
A letter to the editor, from the desk of Mr. Samuel L. Clemens, lately of the river, now of the reason box
To the Editor:
Sir —
I have been shown, by a number of kind correspondents who evidently believe me to be in need of cheering, an announcement from the Flock Safety company of Atlanta, whose cameras now watch the roads of forty-nine states. The announcement was made on the thirteenth of August, and it describes what the firm calls a sweeping overhaul of its protections against misuse. I read it twice, once for information and once for pleasure, and I confess the second reading was the more profitable.
The reform is as follows. Each officer who searches the system for a vehicle will henceforth be required to state a reason. Those departments that had not troubled to switch on the firm’s auditing tool, which I am told was most of them, will be required to use it by year’s end. A user whose activity looks queer will be suspended pending review. The photographs, which used to be kept thirty days, will be kept seven. The company’s own words, as reported in the press, are that a search without a reason is a search that should not happen in the first place.
I know a good sentence when I see one, and I would have been proud of that one myself. I only wish to point out that it is a sentence, with minor changes, that was written into the Fourth Amendment in 1791, and that the persons who adopted it then did not feel obliged to describe it as a sweeping overhaul.
Let me not be hasty. Perhaps the company did not know about the amendment until recently. It has, I am told, been in the business of recording every vehicle that passes a camera, in a network of a hundred and twenty thousand or so, for a good many years. It has, by my count, introduced safeguards of this general kind on at least four separate occasions since the summer of the year before last: a tool to block improper search terms, an optional code for the case being investigated, a menu for the type of offense, and now the same code made mandatory. A man who announces his fourth resolution against a vice in fourteen months has, as a rule, a firm grip on the vice.
I am assured that the earlier tools did not work as well as hoped. One of the people who monitors these things for the American Civil Liberties Union says that officers soon learned that nearly any word would satisfy the machine when it asked for a reason, including a word that I understand to be “hehehe.” I do not blame the officers for this, for I have known men to write a good many things in a box marked “Reason,” and not all of them were in any danger of being believed. I blame the notion that the box was a protection. It is rather like a church that installs a turnstile at the door of the pew and calls the congregation to account for its attendance.
Now let me be fair, since I have been practicing it for some time and find it habit-forming. The company says its tools catch criminals and find missing persons, and in this it has company. The audits it offers have helped uncover some of the very officers who abused it, and a professor of law who has examined the matter says the new rules are better than the opposite. I would not say otherwise. A lock is better than no lock. Nor would I assert, as certain of my correspondents do, that the courts have settled the question of whether this whole business is lawful, for they have not, and a humorist who pronounces judgment on a bench he does not sit on will soon find himself explaining it to a real one.
But I cannot pretend I am satisfied by the answer that the firm is only attending to its own product. A man who builds the ladder and sells it by the thousand, and who learns that a number of the purchasers are climbing in through windows, is not a man to whom I would leave the drawing up of the rules about windows. He is a manufacturer, sir, and he has an interest. By the best count I have seen, there are nearly fifty documented cases of police misuse of the network, and in one of them, I am informed, an officer searched his former sweetheart’s plate five hundred times without any alarm sounding, because the alarm was available but not required. A company that finds its safeguards were optional only after five hundred searches is not a company I would ask to define what a safeguard is.
The better-informed of my correspondents say that the matter ought to be settled by the legislatures and the judges, whose business it is, and by the people, who pay for it. I find I agree with them. The Constitution already contains a rule on the subject. It was not written by a vendor, it is not subject to a firmware update, and it has never, to my knowledge, required a reason of the form “hehehe.”
I remain, sir, as ever,
Mark Twain
(deceased, and, as the cameras are no doubt aware, unavailable for comment)
